Private vs Agency Home Care: Which is Better for Your Family?
When families in Edmonton start looking for home care, they usually find two options: hire through an agency or hire a private (independent) caregiver directly.
The price difference is significant. The care quality can be too, but not always in the direction you'd expect. Here's an honest look at both options.
The Cost Difference
This is the biggest and most immediate difference:
| | Agency | Private Caregiver | |---|--------|-------------------| | You pay | $45-60/hr | $35-40/hr | | Caregiver earns | $19-23/hr | $35-40/hr | | Where the rest goes | Agency overhead, profit | N/A |
With an agency, roughly 50-60% of what you pay goes to the agency, not the person providing your parent's care. That covers their office, management, recruitment, marketing, and profit margin.
With a private caregiver, 100% of what you pay goes to the person in your parent's home.
What That Means in Real Dollars
For a family needing 15 hours of care per week:
- Agency: 15 hrs x $50/hr = $750/week ($3,000/month)
- Private: 15 hrs x $37/hr = $555/week ($2,220/month)
That's a difference of $780/month or $9,360/year.
What Agencies Offer
Agencies aren't just charging more for the same thing. Here's what the markup covers:
The Pros of Agency Care
Backup staffing: If your regular caregiver is sick, the agency sends someone else. You won't have a gap in care.
Administrative handling: The agency manages scheduling, payroll, tax deductions, and workers' compensation insurance.
Liability coverage: Agencies carry professional liability insurance and workers' comp, which protects families.
Regulated structure: Agencies have policies, procedures, and supervisory oversight.
The Cons of Agency Care
Caregiver rotation: Many agencies rotate staff based on availability. Your parent may see 3-4 different people in a week. For seniors with dementia or anxiety, this can be deeply unsettling.
The caregiver is underpaid: When a caregiver earns $19-23/hr while you pay $50/hr, the best caregivers eventually leave agencies to work independently. Agencies often have high turnover as a result.
Less flexibility: Agencies operate on their scheduling systems. Requesting specific times, adding a last-minute visit, or adjusting the care plan often requires going through layers of coordination.
Impersonal: You're a client number. The caregiver follows an agency care plan, not a personal relationship.
What Private Caregivers Offer
The Pros of Private Care
Same person every visit: Your parent builds a real relationship with their caregiver. The caregiver learns their preferences, their morning routine, their favourite tea, their stories. This consistency is especially valuable for seniors with cognitive decline.
Better value: You pay less, and the caregiver earns more. Everyone benefits.
Flexibility: Need to shift Tuesday's visit to Wednesday? Want to add an extra hour this week? Private caregivers can adapt quickly because there's no bureaucratic layer.
Direct communication: You talk directly to the person providing care. No calling an office and leaving a message with a coordinator who relays it to a different coordinator.
Higher motivation: A private caregiver whose livelihood depends on your family's satisfaction has a strong personal incentive to provide exceptional care.
The Cons of Private Care
Backup coverage: If your private caregiver is sick or on vacation, you need a backup plan. Some private caregivers have colleagues they can recommend, but it's not as seamless as an agency's staffing pool.
Due diligence falls on you: You need to verify credentials, check references, and confirm insurance coverage yourself. (Though a good private caregiver will make this easy.)
No organizational oversight: There's no supervisor reviewing care plans or conducting check-ins, unless the caregiver proactively communicates with the family (which good ones do).
How to Decide
Choose an agency if:
- Your parent's needs are medically complex and may require specialized staff
- You have no family nearby to serve as a point of contact
- Administrative convenience is your top priority
- You're comfortable with caregiver rotation
Choose a private caregiver if:
- Consistency (same person every visit) is important to your family
- Your parent has dementia or anxiety around strangers
- You want more value for your money
- Flexibility in scheduling matters
- You value a personal, trust-based relationship
Questions to ask a private caregiver before hiring:
- Can I see your HCA certification and criminal record check?
- How many years of experience do you have?
- Can I speak with 2-3 references?
- What's your backup plan if you're unavailable?
- Do you carry liability insurance?
- What are your rates, and is there a minimum visit length?
Our Approach
At Adjo's Touch, we chose the private care model intentionally. Here's why:
- Adjo provides every visit personally - your parent always sees the same face
- 11+ years of HCA experience with zero complaints
- Transparent pricing at $35-40/hr with no hidden fees
- Direct communication with Prince (business manager) and Adjo (caregiver)
- Flexible scheduling - we work around your family's needs, not ours
We believe families deserve to know exactly where their money goes, and the person caring for their parent deserves to be fairly compensated. The private model makes both possible.
Topics
